What's new
Fingers of Suspicion

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Search results

  1. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Also... these hidden rules, 4 can be presumed...

    1. No reaching hammer results in a death... we saw the final person on the leading train bite the bullet, but revived to push home the importance of following the rules.
    2. Voting for the mod results in a self vote... Is this a rule or do we feel void was just fucking with them?

    MMO-C people... what were some other hidden rules in previous games? what else do we think could be out there that we need to navigate? Wasnt one not being able to say lurker?
  2. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    Every game I worry about val. And every game I get told it's just val. And in fairness, that's usually what it is. but it can't always be.

    So, I support BN in trying to get more info there.
    Click to expand...
    I feel the same about @morrison , @llettuce and @Peter Griffin Nearly zero thread presence from them all game and no individual opinions placed

    COME OUT AND PLAY!!!
  3. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    Vote: Kareemah

    I'm not sure I can add anything else on today's read.


    The thing to keep in mind on the past reads to identify scum, you have to look at where there's certainty. On a normal read, they won't know who's on the other team. So even a good read on someone who is dirty, doesn't rule them out for one.

    As well-I agree with most of Psych's spreadsheeting, but am not ruling out treachery for some characters where the flavor makes sense (filch, moody, etc). And of course there's going to be at least some bastardness in actions.

    The account of wishes, particularly since Scum got one, is also a factor I'm considering.
    Click to expand...
    I agree that Kareem is more or less a forgone conclusion... but with more then 24hrs left in the phase and several people not even checking in on the day or giving any true input to the thread, we have time before we need to drive home the hammer.

    Your vote puts it at L-2, if I can count
  4. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Val the Moofia Boss said:
    Nope. I don't usually get feels on people until several game days into a game.
    Click to expand...
    We are several game days into the game and you've been one of the few with incredible little thread presence. What else do you need to get involved and give your own feels/opinions?
  5. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Val the Moofia Boss said:
    It seems that Diva is a TPR who caught Kareemah visiting someone who got hit by an NK or scum night action? That seems to be the lynch today. If Kareemah flips town then we can look at Diva, or perhaps other information will come to light tomorrow.

    Vote: Kareemah
    Click to expand...
    So in the other 3 days of gameplay, do you have any other reads/opinions...

    Nearly everyone has said/seen/agreed with the fact that Kareem has been caught. Anything else you care to contribute? or ask to other players?
  6. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    @Val the Moofia Boss @morrison @Peter Griffin @llettuce More participation from you guys is needed

    Any reads? We are days into with several writeups of actions in hand.

    also, why @Lora did you not want to give all houses a bonus? And if it was going to fail, I knew it would have been you without looking at the thread.
  7. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    You'd guess Peeves or alliance based on last night. Could be a different play though.
    Click to expand...
    Guess i need to go reread SOD.

    Thanks for pushing my name to peoples thoughts for rez though
  8. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Kareemah said:
    U keep teaming with him and it doesn’t look well in my books, I’ve gotten him down to either death eater or alliance
    Click to expand...
    If multiple people got the same read from the NAs in the start of day post... doesnt mean they are teamed. Hell, they could all potentially be teamed as Order of the Phoenix. People do interpret the actions similarly as has been discussed on previous days after reading the writeups
  9. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Ill point put again morri survived x2 attacks and still lives..
    Click to expand...
    Feels dirty to me as well... You feeling Peeves or in the DE/Alliance catagory?
  10. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Hes not clean and right now kareem is saying mazer isnt clean either
    Click to expand...
    If you look at Caito from N1, vote on mazer coming back into d2... looks like potential for deets.

    Do we feel Drey is clean? I dont like the way yesterday ended

    Just getting my sus list together
  11. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Lets start by saying, Thank You Hagrid for the rez. Much appreciated.

    Im not too sure on your read of Drey by stopping the lynch. Drey is high on my list.

    Also want to give a should out to Peeves and Voldy ....
    FUCK YOU

    Looks like Kareem is on the block today. Kinda see why with NAs.

    Feel like Jarrod is sus based on a couple things said... Might have to go find it again, but it felt like a TMI slip. Why is Jarrod clean? Or is he not clean yet?
  12. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    I tried... but the anagram solver I previously used (higher character limit and did phrases), couldnt be found again. Maybe I should have bookmarked it, because it was hella useful.

    Nice work. Tried to help with consolidating and bringing the riddle closer to the bottom f the thread to make things easier.
  13. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    of the 2 that were right, my guess would be 1 and 2... think 3 and 4 have work to do
  14. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Satsu said:
    Are those all confirmed to fit?
    Click to expand...
    I didnt verify them, I just looked through and copied all the ones people were guessing, figuring.

    think most of that work goes to Xan, 3pup, Tildey... iirc
  15. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Here it is again to no have to go back...

    Night 1 Puzzle:

    eveorhnienaolstDtds - 6 Words - 2, 3, fear, 3, 6, 5
    ordCauwrodnnlyae - 6 Words - 5, 4, mind, 3, calm, 4
    aeeWnesereotvfiwsushhotstr - 6 Words - 7, 6, 5, 4, phrases, 4
    ntattenifemeVytvdsrposeikerobsihtadnoi - 9 Words - 10, 2, 3, 4, moderator, 3, 2, 8, 6
  16. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts


    Do not fear the devil snares
    Do not fear the devil's snare
    Do not fear the island verse.
    Do not fear her silent saved

    Clear your mind and calm down.

    Whoever wishes notes fast phrases true
    Whoever wishes stone true phrases fast
    Whoever wishes notes true phrases fast
    Whoever writes notes shut phrases safe

    Voidkitten is the best moderator for my paranoid events



    I think this is a consolidation of all the thoughts
  17. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    morrison said:
    weigh in on what? the fucking banter? if i have a thought on something, i'll post it.
    Click to expand...
    So you dont care if your potentially in danger because you arent reaching 10 posts in the phase?
  18. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    MTR said:
    because we never really push anyone on day one because there is no information and most people just shit post.
    Click to expand...
    The issue is too many lazy people not willing to do ANYTHING.

    It is entirely possible to get action out of the day. But too many are willing to sit back and let it go to sleep. Or post once or twice, then vanish for the remainder of the phase. I hope this game is damn near impossible to spreadsheet, because people are just waiting for NAs to start.
  19. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Randolph said:
    My first crush was Large Marge from Pee-Wee's Big Adventure
    Click to expand...
    Wonderful, any opinions on Day1 of the game?
    Randolph said:
    Who the hell is Lettuce?
    Click to expand...
    Someone that signed up and hasnt posted at all
  20. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    CWE said:
    Unvote: caito
    :squint:

    Your right (Vote) Caito. Shooting you is more fun. Plus that train is dirty.

    I get my reason (he's breathing), what's everyone else's? And don't just say to lynch someone day 1.
    Click to expand...
    My reason is to have a vote out...

    I wont vote sleep. So figured go with the other train to see if we can make something of the day.

    Remember, its Majority lynch, so we need to hit 13 voters to even secure a lynch. Day not ending in majority, will result in a no lynch. One reason why I think voting sleep/no lynch is lazy as fuck. We've had plenty of time to interact and start forming opinions on people. Yet, we really havent pushed anyone
  21. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Caito said:
    Sure. It’s D1. We all know my thoughts on D1 and the absolute bullshit it is, as well as you don’t actually get anywhere near the info some people swear they do.


    Wake me up when we are past it and you’ll get more outta me
    Click to expand...
    So you dont feel like engaging in discussions and want to coast past d1.

    Only time info comes from d1 is when people interact.

    Unvote:
    Vote: Caito
  22. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    We have several people that are nowhere near the 10 recommended posts of the OP.

    Lettuce - 0
    Jarrod - 1
    PG - 2
    Val - 3
    Morrison - 4
    Caito, Diva, Randolph - 6
    Listo - 8
    Drey, Future, Kareem - 9

    Doubt there will be heavy modkills, but the activity recommendation might in place because someone can do things to lurkers? Maybe Peeves deals with inactivity instead of non-voters?

    But with that said

    Vote: Jarrod
    Come out and play

    @llettuce @Jarrod1983 @Peter Griffin @Val the Moofia Boss @morrison @Caito @DivaSmurf @Randolph Game has been going over 48 hours and you lot have participated the least in the game. Care to weigh in?
  23. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    3puppies said:
    Anyhow, to keep discussion on the game at hand, with 25 players, it might seem that red and purple will be at equal strength, yellow is neutral/jester?, and we have identified half so far as belonging to the blue good guys. For those that have run games before, how many of each red/purple do you think we should expect?
    Click to expand...
    to get to the bottom part... 25 ppl with 1/3 scum, 2/3 town would make it 8/16/1

    1 for peeves, not counting Nightingale since she is the 26th.

    so either a 16/4/4/1 if even teams (5/3 split for scum at worst)

    potentially a 14/5/5/1 or 14/6/4/1
  24. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    3puppies said:
    Don't mean to put you in the "dog house of MTR"

    Should it be "House of Tildey & MTR" then, or "house of MTR & Tildey"

    Teamwork makes the dream work

    Anyhow, to keep discussion on the game at hand, with 25 players, it might seem that red and purple will be at equal strength, yellow is neutral/jester?, and we have identified half so far as belonging to the blue good guys. For those that have run games before, how many of each red/purple do you think we should expect?
    Click to expand...
    Last game it was the House that Future built
  25. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Nightingale said:
    I'm quite certain no one will be replacing he who shall not be named's wand with a string of spaghetti, as amusing as that would be to see!
    Click to expand...
    That would be highly entertaining... and the only spells would be tossing meatballs
  26. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Badger said:
    A tough but fair evaluation so will take the $25. These are quick D1 reads overall so haven’t analysed. As far as Lora goes, that was more a read on his general style but the cloak is something I haven’t considered yet. The only ones I’m fairly confident of being steel so far in those are CWE and Blind. I think I’m bumping 3pups a bit ever so slightly after that last post. Psych I still want to see more of in case that wasn’t entirely clear. I’ve played with him long enough never to go full on this early.
    Click to expand...
    Do we think Lora had the cloak as an ability, or do we think VK did it to ensure Lora had a chance to play the game. Lora died N1 last game and I dont think he's done any Rajah games.
  27. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    3puppies said:
    Red
    Voldemort
    Peter Pettigrew
    Death Eaters
    Lucious Malfoy

    Purple
    Gellert Grindewald
    Nagel
    Alliance
    Vinda Rosier

    Yellow
    Trelawney (wish granter aka Nightengale)
    Peeves

    Blue
    Harry Potter (NOT CWE)
    Fred Weasley
    Marauders Map
    Albus Dumbledore
    Minverva McGonagall
    George Weasley
    Dobby
    Rubeus Hagrid
    Argus Filch
    Mrs. Norris
    Luna Lovegood

    This is my starting spreadsheet before I add what I know of my own character's info. I would appreciate anyone who can check this in case I missed something.

    Most of the other games I have not been as familiar with the source material. So by now, I suspect there will be shenanigans designed to mess with spreadsheeters. For example, I wonder if Marauders Map is a character, and why we don't see Ginny and Ron Weasley, nor Hermione Granger or Neville Longbottom. Alliance and Death Eaters also seem to be suspect to me - are they real characters, or more likely decoys? Where is Severus Snape? Draco Malfoy? Could Filch and Mrs. Norris be red herrings on the blue team?
    Click to expand...
    Snape was mentioned (d1 intro)
    Death Eaters and The Alliance feel more like groups of people (teams) and not an individual. Grindewald was the leader of the Alliance
  28. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    CWE said:
    Your tell for me is NNAI. If it's right...
    Click to expand...
    So what alignment do you feel I am based on the interaction
  29. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    CWE said:
    Your tell for me is NNAI. If it's right...
    Click to expand...
    Say again
  30. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Dreyski said:
    I should probably lay off RDR2 because I’m now imagining Badger as Uncle, you as John, and Claws as Jack Marston.

    Wondering if the Badger/BN interaction yesterday was indicative of anything significant.
    Click to expand...
    I clash in some way with people all the time... NAI for me
  31. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Tildey said:
    Something I found interesting is that Marauder’s Map is in blue. So is the map somehow a character in its own right? A mousekatool perhaps?
    Click to expand...
    If the map is a player, I would assume its a tracker or watcher type
  32. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Guess I should read my rolecard...

    Order of the Pheonix is town. Always helps to know who/what I am when I start playing
  33. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Kareemah said:
    Oh god, I didn’t realize we started and missed so much 😭 but I’m ready 😼 how do we find cult if we can’t call out our roles
    Click to expand...
    No cult... based on colors and names...

    Death Eaters appears to be a scum team
    The Alliance appears to be some other team
    I assume names in     blue are likely to be the town element of this setup
    Sybill (Nightingale) is listed as a neutral and untargetable. Peeves is also listed, so assume neutral of some sorts
  34. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Nightingale said:
    Hrm. No, I don't think? Maybe? No, no, the vibrations of my crystals don't see that.
    Click to expand...
    random reactions to thread or a wish that came to you?
  35. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    3puppies said:
    I want to get a vote in because I don't trust what can happen by not voting, or by voting sleep.

    Vote: Val the Moofia Boss

    No reason other than the suggestion to lynch the no lynchers
    Click to expand...
    I dont see anything suggesting punishment for nonvoters. Only thing I see is recommending at least 10 posts per phase
  36. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    MTR said:
    Any show like that is labeled reality.

    Probably the only reality show that was really reality or as close as you get to it was the first season of the Real World but even then there was creative editing.
    Click to expand...
    100% of shows like that use creative editing to add more drama or make it the least bit entertaining. Thousands of hours of video to roll into a 30min-1hr episode
  37. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    PsychoSoldier said:
    You're not determined enough
    Click to expand...
    I agree with this... I just said it was frowned upon
  38. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    MTR said:
    Spoiler alert. All reality shows are scripted. Some more than others and some are just plain fake like an episode of Jerry Springer starring Memphis wrestling star Bill Dundee and his son J.C. Ice former member of the Nation.
    Click to expand...
    Was pawn stars originally labeled as a reality show?

    Either way, Im well aware that the vast majority of shows are scripted and completely true
  39. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    images


    The Old Man likes to get in the show somehow
    Click to expand...
    That show is scripted... it was entertaining before I learned that fact, but I can never see it the same again.
  40. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    The Homely Man said:
    The thing about a psycho first push is that sometimes he likes to do it, because it's the most memorable one. And he might no he's gonna get checked soon. And sometimes you've got a big pile of nothing. And if I'm going to move a product, I've gotta know what it's worth. Otherwise it's just taking up shelf space.

    blind ninja has been analyzing matthieu votes since 1983, and is considered one of the foremost evaluators of his triggers in the viking larping community. @Blind Ninja, what type of appraisal would you put on that vote?
    Click to expand...
    I put it at an attempt to not hold discussion for the day. We've already had 1 person say something to the point of "we have no info," but what effort are they making to converse, ask questions and formulate opinions.

    I can see moving votes around for reactions and interacting with people, only to move to no vote late in the cycle, but within the 1st several hours just feels lazy. On top of the fact that we need Majority to lynch, voting sleep/no lynch isnt even needed when nobody is close to danger.
  41. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Blind Ninja said:
    I take the son/grandson BS and some gimmick he wants to roll with... and dont read into that much. Its on the back burner and might come back to depending on how things shake up
    Click to expand...
    as some gimmick... not and some gimmick
  42. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Satsu said:
    What if he is lying about being Claws granddad too. :rolleyes:
    Click to expand...
    I take the son/grandson BS and some gimmick he wants to roll with... and dont read into that much. Its on the back burner and might come back to depending on how things shake up
  43. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Lora said:
    are you trying to bait me into claiming and getting me modkilled? thats really cringe.
    Click to expand...
    Asking questions for reactions... not the one I was expecting, but results for me to gauge regardless
  44. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Badger said:
    Well it’s pretty common knowledge I’m a UK poster and it’s evening here.
    Click to expand...
    That assumes I remember you're a UK poster...

    But you see how it could be construed in the OP of yours

    Unvote:
  45. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    MTR said:
    No Way Bird GIF
    Click to expand...
    but I like my #13
  46. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Lora said:
    Vote:

    Blind Ninja​
    Click to expand...
    let me guess, you're cop and got a n0 guilty on me?
  47. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Badger said:
    Aye because I’m that daft to post it and post 3 times when perhaps…here’s a shock, maybe no longer at work.
    Click to expand...
    The tone and direction of the 1st post made it seem like you were at work... then not knowing where you are, and based on my current time, inferred it was still normal working hours for you. Can you not see how that would corrilate?
  48. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Claws said:
    Yes if your not first your last ricky bobbi
    Click to expand...
    Shake And Bake GIF by The Heckler by TBS
  49. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    VoidKitten said:
    1. 3puppies
    2. Badger
    3. Blind Ninja
    4. Caito
    5. Claws
    6. CWE
    7. DivaSmurf
    8. Dreyski
    9. FutureHold
    10. Jarrod1983
    11. Kareemah
    12. Llettuce
    13. Listo
    14. Lora
    15. Matthieu
    16. Morrison
    17. MTR
    18. Peter Griffin
    19. Psycho666Soldier
    20. Randolph
    21. Satsu
    22. The Homely Man
    23. Tildey
    24. Val
    25. Xanjori
    —---------------
    26. Nightingale - Sybill Trelawney
    Click to expand...

    Anyone else upset that this got changed to alphabetical order instead of number you signed up for?
  50. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    So you initial checkin with... and not able to wifi at work... yet you post 3 times in under an hour... seems disingenuous

    Unvote:
    Vote: badger
  51. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    @Nightingale Aside from chatting during the day and granting a wish each night (should you chose to do so)... Do you have a win-con you are working towards (not asking what it is) or are you just here to engage and grant
  52. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Randolph said:
    Why is milk the only bodily fluid that we're allowed to drink in public?
    Click to expand...
    Im sure you could drink other fluids... its not disallowed, just highly frowned upon.

    You do you
  53. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    MTR said:
    What is rude is that people keep killing me while I am sleeping. Can't a man take a nap in peace.
    Click to expand...
    did you kill your entire family or portions of it 2 games in a row?
  54. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Nightingale said:
    How's your progress coming along, hm? Do you feel the connection with the divine yet? Let me see your cup chil-- oh my! Oh.. oh no... are you feeling quite well? Have you run across any salamanders recently? No? Well... keep your eyes open, and if you do - run!
    Click to expand...
    Too much effort to run, Ill just walk. Might be a brisk walk.

    And not sure the tea was doing much, so moved on to coffee
  55. Blind Ninja

    Mafia 2 - Wishes of Hogwarts

    Damn... I was gonna come in and vote nightingale... but can

    Vote: PG

    Welcome to the party
Top Bottom